1958

Jim Baxes

Art Fowler

Jim Gentile

Glen Gorbous

Connie Grob

Ralph Mauriello

Bob Milliken

Ed Palmquist

Tony Roig

Tom Saffell

Dick Scott

Larry Sherry

Norm Sherry

Maury Wills

Dick Young

1959

Steve Bilko

Bobby Bragan

Roger Craig

Tommy Davis

Chuck Essegian

Bob Giallombardo

Johnny Gray

Dave Hoskins

Frank Howard

Bob Lillis

Lloyd Merritt

Don Miles

Larry Miller

Phil Ortega

Phil Paine

Tom Saffell

Gene Snyder

Ben Wade

1960

Mike Brumley

Chuck Churn

Ramón Conde

Willie Davis

Ron Fairly

Joe Frazier

Bill Harris

Mel Nelson

George O'Donnell

Jim Pagliaroni

Ed Rakow

Curt Roberts

Earl Robinson

Ed Sadowski

Ray Semproch

Elmer Singleton

Roy Smalley

Charley Smith

1961

Fred Besana

Don Bessent

Bob Bowman

Larry Burright

Diug Camilli

Choo-Choo Coleman

Mike Goliat

Rod Graber

Tim Harkness

Joe Moeller

Don Newcombe

Nate Oliver

Ernie Oravetz

Howie Reed

Pete Richert

Jim Stump

René Valdés

1962

Nelson Chittum

Al Ferrara

Stan Johnson

Dick Nen

Nate Oliver

Bobby Prescott

Ken Rowe

Thad Tillotson

Dick Tracewski

Johnny Werhas

1963

Jim Barbieri

Don LeJohn

Ken McMullen

Danny Ozark

Bart Shirley

Jack Smith

Héctor Valle

Nick Willhite

1964

Marv Breeding

Derrell Griffith

Lou Johnson

Mike Kekich

Jim Lefebvre

Gordon MacKenzie

John Purdin

Bill Singer

1965

Bob Baird

Jack Billingham

Ted Bowsfield

Dick Calmus

Gino Cimoli

1966

Tommy Dean

Dick Egan

Tommy Hutton

Stan Williams

1967

Bruce Brubaker

Gordy Coleman

Jack Cullen

Jim Fairey

Mike Ferraro

Jerry Fosnow

Alan Foster

Cleo James

Bruce Look

John Miller

Fred Norman

Roy White

1968

Luis Alcaraz

Jim Campanis

Willie Crawford

Jim Duffalo

John Duffie

Leon Everitt

Bill Heath

Ted Sizemore

Mike Strahler

Don Sutton

Sandy Vance

1969

Bill Buckner

Bobby Darwin

Chuck Goggin

Billy Grabarkewitz

Von Joshua

Ray Lamb

Jimmie Schaffer

Jack Spring

Bob Stinson

Bobby Valentine

1970

Doyle Alexander

Steve Garvey

Charlie Hough

Jack Jenkins

Davey Lopes

Bob O'Brien

Tom Paciorek

José Peña

Bill Russell

Doug Rau

Jerry Stephenson

Geoff Zahn

1971

Ron Cey

Bill Edgerton

Bruce Ellingsen

Joe Ferguson

Bob Gallagher

Tim Johnson

Bob Randall

Sergio Robles

Hoyt Wilhelm

1972

Glenn Burke