Single Game Individual Records

Batting

Most At-Bats: 8, several (Last - Jodd Carter: 8/17/2016 vs. West Michigan)
Most Hits: 5, several (Last - Bobby Ison: 8/17/2016 vs. West Michigan)
Most Runs: 5 (Carlos Moncrief: 7/21/2011 vs. Quad Cities)
Most RBI: 8, 2x (Last - Will Benson: 4/18/2019 vs. South Bend)
Most Home Runs: 4 (Will Benson: 4/18/2019 vs. South Bend)
Most Doubles: 3, several (Last - Clark Scolamiero: 8/12/2019 vs. West Michigan)
Most Triples: 2, several (Last - Johnathan Rodriguez 4/9/2022 @ Lansing)
Most Walks: 6 (Francisco Lindor: 6/14/2012 vs. South Bend)
Most Strikeouts: 5, 5x (Last - Jhonkensy Noel 6/23/2022 @ Dayton)
Most Stolen Bases: 4, 2x (Last - Tyler Friis: 6/3/2018 at South Bend)

On April 18, 2019, Will Benson became the first player in Captains history to hit four home runs in a game. He was just the fifth player in Midwest League history to accomplish the feat.

Pitching & Fielding

Juan Mota set a Captains record for strikeouts in a seven-inning complete game with eight against West Michigan on July 1, 2019. He also tied Captains records for fewest hits (2) and fewest walks (0) in a seven-inning complete game.

Roberto Hernández, pictured during a 2008 rehab appearance, set Captains records for fewest hits (4) and fewest walks (0) in a nine-inning complete game shutout on July 22, 2003 against Hagerstown.

Adam Plutko owns the Captains record for most strikeouts in a game with 13 against Bowling Green on May 8, 2014.

Most Innings Pitched: 9, 4x (Last - Brett Brach: 7/24/2010 vs. Peoria)
Fewest Hits Allowed in a Shutout (9 IP): 4 (Roberto Hernández: 7/22/2003 vs. Hagerstown)
Fewest Walks Allowed in a Shutout (9 IP): 0 (Roberto Hernández: 7/22/2003 vs. Hagerstown)
Most Strikeouts in a Shutout (9 IP): 5, 2x (Last - Brett Brach: 7/24/2010 vs. Peoria)
Fewest Hits Allowed in a Complete Game (9 IP): 3, 2x (Last - Aaron Laffey: 7/7/2005 vs. Delmarva)
Fewest Walks Allowed in a Complete Game (9 IP): 0, 2x (Last - Roberto Hernández: 7/22/2003 vs. Hagerstown)
Most Strikeouts in a Complete Game (9 IP): 8 (Jake Dittler: 5/8/2003 vs. Kannapolis)
Fewest Hits Allowed in a Shutout (7 IP): 2, 2x (Last - Jordan Milbrath: 4/5/2014 vs. Lansing - Game 2)
Fewest Walks Allowed in a Shutout (7 IP): 0 (Keith Ramsey: 6/15/2003 vs. Hagerstown - Game 1)
Most Strikeouts in a Shutout (7 IP): 5, 2x (Last - Jordan Milbrath: 4/5/2014 vs. Lansing - Game 2)
Fewest Hits Allowed in a Complete Game (7 IP): 2, 3x (Last - Juan Mota: 7/1/2019 at West Michigan - Game 1)
Fewest Walks Allowed in a Complete Game (7 IP): 0, 4x (Last - Juan Mota: 7/1/2019 at West Michigan - Game 1)
Most Strikeouts in a Complete Game (7 IP): 8 (Juan Mota: 7/1/2019 at West Michigan - Game 1)
Most Hits Allowed: 13 (Kyle Blair: 4/15/2012 vs. Bowling Green)
Most Runs Allowed: 14, 2x (Last - Juan Hillman: 7/31/2017 at West Michigan)
Most Home Runs Allowed: 6 (Zach Draper: 8/24/2021 vs. Great Lakes)
Most Hit Batters: 3, several (Last - Kyle Blair: 5/24/2011 at South Bend)
Most Walks: 8, 2x (Last - Trey Haley: 8/27/2010 vs. Bowling Green)
Most Strikeouts: 13 (Adam Plutko: 5/8/2014 vs. Bowling Green)
Most Balks: 2, 7x (Last - Jean Carlos Mejía: 7/25/2018 at West Michigan)
Most Wild Pitches: 5, 2x (Last - Wander Beras: 6/26/2014 at Bowling Green)
Most Errors: 4 (Dorssys Paulino: 4/14/2014 vs. Peoria)

Captains Single Game Individual Records

Batting

Pitching & Fielding