Looking Back: Cy Young Pitches In Nashville
Seraphs' games were played at Athletic Park, which later became Sulphur Dell. Exhibition games were played in the preseason against major league teams, local athletic clubs and Vanderbilt University.
An ad was located in an old Nashville newspaper announcing an April exhibition game with Nashville vs. Ted Sullivan's Wild Texas Steers. Admission prices included: Ladies-Opera Grand Stand 50 cents, Smokers-Grand Stand 40 cents, Bleachers 25 cents. Ladies accompanied by gentlemen, admitted to Grand Stand free on Fridays.
One of these major league teams that stopped in Nashville for an April three-game series was the Cleveland Spiders. The Spiders were members of the 12-team National League. The American League would not be established until 1901.
One of the players on the Spiders roster was a 28-year old future Baseball Hall of Fame member and the all-time winningest pitcher-Cy Young. Young was entering his sixth season with Cleveland and already was unbelievable. He recorded these victory totals in 1890 (9-6), 1891 (27-22), 1892 (36-12), 1893 (34-16) and 1894 (26-21).
Leading Nashville was player-manager George Stallings, who had a brief major league career as a player with Brooklyn (1890) and Philadelphia (1897) of the National League. Stallings had a successful 13-year managing career with four different teams sprinkled between 1897 and 1920. He led the Boston Braves to the 1914 World Series championship.
The Nashville American reported on the third game of this April series, which Young pitched:
The "Spiders" suffered another defeat at the hands of the locals at Athletic Park yesterday afternoon. A good-sized crowd of "fans" witnessed the performance. The game was the best played here this season, being hotly contested from start to finish. The feature was Moran's pitching and hitting, while Trost fairly captured the "fans" by stealing a run off the visitors.
The Cleveland boys put up a great game of ball, but could not find Moran's curves at proper times. Again their mascot "Rastus," failed to wield his power over the umpire; in fact, he seemed to be pulling his left finger for the home boys. Young's pitching was deserving, and the support he received was above average.
Sam Moran was the Seraphs ace pitcher. He would compile a 22-12 record with 34 starts that season. Mike Trost was the Seraphs catcher that batted .288 (79-for-274) in 1895.
The American continued:
In the second inning Moran hit a hot one to left field, as it was doubtful as to whether it was a fair or foul ball. The umpire called it a fair ball and Moran made a home run. Sweeney, who was on first, scored also.
In the third inning the Cleveland's made two runs. Young got first on a hot liner to right field and Zimmer hit to centre field for three bags. Young scored.
In the seventh Moran found Young's curve for a home run. He knocked the sphere over the right field fence and Stallings cried "watch it over."
Nashville won the meaningless exhibition game, 4-3. Young went the distance and took the loss while giving up nine hits. He was 3-for-4 as a batter with the one run scored. Young also added his name of baseball greats to have played on Nashville's historic ball field.
Cleveland finished the 1895 season in second place (84-46) with manager Patsy Tebeau. Young led the league with a 35-10 record in 47 games and 370 innings.
Young pitched for St. Louis in 1899-1900 before he joined the Boston Red Sox of the newly formed American League. He pitched for the Red Sox for nine seasons then finished his career with Cleveland (1909-11) and Boston Braves (1911).
In 22 seasons, Young's record was an astonishing 511-315 for a .619 percentage. He appeared in 906 career games with a lifetime 2.63 ERA. Young pitched 7,356 innings with 750 complete games and 76 shutouts. He also had five 30-win seasons and his 315 defeats is also a record. Denny McLain is the last 30-game winner in the major leagues with his 31-6 feat in 1968.
Young was a charter member of the National Baseball Hall of Fame in 1936. The award for the most outstanding pitcher in the National and American League is named for Cy Young. Young died in Newcomerstown, Ohio in 1955 at age 88.
The Seraphs won a controversial league title over Atlanta. Several disputed games were excluded while some researchers give the pennant to Atlanta. The Nashville newspapers document the hearings involved in determining the champion and they report Nashville was declared the winners.
Nashville's franchise folded after that 1895 championship season. The Southern League folded in 1899 and the Nashville Vols would be charter members of the newly-formed Southern Association in 1901. The Vols remained in the association until 1961 when the league folded. The Vols became members of the SALLY League in 1963, the final season for the club.
Traughber's Tidbit: This newspaper article was found in a Nashville newspaper in April 1911. "Baseball on Skates at Hippodrome:" Baseball on skates is the latest attraction, which the fertile mind of Manager Bordeiser has evolved to entertain the large crowds which nightly flock to the Hippodrome. The game will be pulled off next Tuesday night, and the two teams are practicing daily for the contest, which will be one of the most novel ones ever witnessed in the city. As every fan knows it is a difficult matter to play baseball on terra firms, but when it comes to being handicapped by a pair of skates one naturally concludes that the task is something fierce. However, the boys are being quite proficient in chasing flies and circling the bases on the ball-bearing little wheels, and will no doubt give a most entertaining exhibition next Tuesday night.
If you have any comments or suggestions, click here to send an email to Bill Traughber.
Don't sleep on these prospects at Spring Breakout -- 1 from each team
The second edition of Spring Breakout is bursting with high-profile prospects. Seventy members of MLB Pipeline’s Top 100 are slated to participate, including Red Sox outfielder Roman Anthony (No. 2), Tigers outfielder Max Clark (No. 6), Red Sox infielder Kristian Campbell (No. 7), Rays shortstop Carson Williams (No. 9) and
Meet the 14 women who run MiLB teams
From California to Massachusetts, from Arkansas to Iowa, leadership in professional baseball is evolving. Coming into the 2025 season, there are 14 women in general manager positions across Minor League Baseball. When most fans think of the GMs in baseball, they likely assume the job is all about building a
2024 Draft class gets early chance to take center stage at Spring Breakout
When players are taken in the early rounds of the MLB Draft, it’s easy to dream about seeing them under the bright lights of the big leagues, but a common refrain has been that fans don't get to see those players for years after they're selected. Thanks to Spring Breakout,
From Spring Breakout to MLB? Here are nine players who could soon be in The Show
The inaugural Spring Breakout in 2024 provided a platform for fans to meet many of baseball's top prospects before they began standing out in the Majors shortly thereafter. Paul Skenes striking out Jackson Holliday. Jackson Chourio reaching twice and scoring a run. Jace Jung hitting a pair of homers.
Brewers' 17-year-old international signee draws comparisons to Chourio
PHOENIX – A farm system loses an elite-level prospect like Jackson Chourio, who was the No. 2 overall prospect in baseball at the start of the 2024 season, to the big leagues, it’s easy to understand that it would take a hit in this year’s farm system rankings. So don’t
Cubs have MLB stars AND loaded farm system
MESA, Ariz. – It’s a testament to where a farm system is when a Top 100-caliber hitter gets traded away and there’s still a desire to tout the bats. The Cubs traded Cam Smith to the Astros in the Kyle Tucker deal, but they still have seven players on the
Griffin boosts Pirates system, known for producing arms, with some pop
BRADENTON, Fla. – The Pirates’ strength in pitching is obvious. This is the organization that drafted Paul Skenes after all and saw him become the National League All-Star starter one year later. Jared Jones and Mitch Keller serve as more developmental success stories on the bump, and Top 100 prospects
New Rays prospect additions fitting right into the organizational mold
PORT CHARLOTTE, Fla. -- Thirteen members of the Rays’ Top 30 prospect list weren’t in the organization at this time last year. Two arrived in the 2024 Draft, one was a 2025 international signee and a whopping 10 have come over in trades since last March. Normally with that level
Headlined by big-name bats, Mariners' system strong on pitching depth, too
PEORIA, Ariz. -- The Mariners placed fifth in MLB Pipeline's new farm system rankings, thanks in large part to their seven Top 100 Prospects. That total ties them with the Cubs for the most in baseball, and all seven of them are hitters. Don't get the impression that the organization
All eyes turn to hurlers Sykora, Susana in Nats camp
WEST PALM BEACH, Fla. -- Last year in Spring Training, Nationals manager Dave Martinez named the section of young hitting prospects in big league camp led by James Wood and Dylan Crews "Hope Row." While Robert Hassell III and Brady House are still prospects, Wood has graduated and Crews will
Here are the prospects with the best tools in Spring Breakout
The inaugural edition of Spring Breakout was a rousing success last year. Sixteen games showcased not only many of baseball's best prospects but also some of the most jaw-dropping tools in the Minors. Of the 10 best individual attributes we highlighted a year ago, nine belonged to players who reached
Boston's 'Core Four' hitting principles breeding prospect success
FORT MYERS, Fla. – Boston was built to be a shining city on a hill, according to John Winthrop. Four centuries later, the Hub’s top three baseball prospects are meant to be a shining example atop the Red Sox farm system. Roman Anthony, Kristian Campbell and Marcelo Mayer – the
Phils' teen catching prospect using ABS challenge experience to his advantage
CLEARWATER, Fla. – One of the storylines of Spring Training has been the implementation of the ABS challenge system in select ballparks across Arizona and Florida. But those in the Sunshine State might be a little more familiar with the tech than their southwestern counterparts. The Florida State League first
Texas' exciting crop of pitching prospects looks to spin the narrative
SURPRISE, Ariz. -- The Rangers haven't signed a fully homegrown pitching All-Star since Martín Pérez in 2007 and have ranked better than the Major League average in run prevention just once in the last 11 seasons. Not coincidentally, they won 90 games and the World Series when that happened in
The 10 best 2025 Spring Breakout rosters, ranked
Ding, ding, who’s ready for Round 2? Last year’s inaugural edition of Spring Breakout gave fans early looks at Paul Skenes, Jackson Chourio, Pete Crow-Armstrong, James Wood, Jackson Holliday, Ceddanne Rafaela and many other young stars who graduated off prospect lists in 2024. Not only does it serve as a
Yankees' prospect gains coming up long at short
TAMPA, Fla. -- The Yankees have a fascinating shortstop decision on their hands. You could say it’s the most interesting one since you-know-who retired in 2014. New York is battling going with a veteran presence in Isiah Kiner-Falefa or a prospect in Anthony Volpe or Oswald Peraza. It’s still too
Mets looking for top prospects to complement veteran stars
PORT ST. LUCIE, Fla. -- The last time Juan Soto played in a Minor League game was back in 2018, when in the span of 39 games at age 19 he went from A ball to High-A to Double-A and then to the big leagues with the Nationals and never
'Eephus' director Lund talks movie on podcast
Check out the latest episodes of The Show Before the Show, MiLB.com's official podcast. A segment rundown is listed below, in case you want to skip to a particular section. Like the podcast? Subscribe, rate and review on Apple Podcasts. The podcast is also available via Spotify, Megaphone and other
Minors radio legend exits the booth in Birmingham
Benjamin Hill travels the nation collecting stories about what makes Minor League Baseball unique. This excerpt from his newsletter is a mere taste of the smorgasbord of delights he offers every week. Read the full newsletter here, and subscribe to his newsletter here.
MLB's 2025 farm system rankings -- with a new No. 1
It’s time to crown a new king. After a three-year run for the Orioles atop our preseason farm system rankings, they’ve stepped off the throne, making way for the Tigers. The O’s had slipped from the top spot in our 2024 midseason rankings as they’d graduated a number of prospects