30th Season
Voted on by fans in 2023
C - Adley Rutschman
1B - Trey Mancini
2B - Justin Turner
3B - David Wright
SS - Gunnar Henderson (Picture shown to right)
OF - Austin Hays
OF - Cedric Mullins
OF - Mike Yastrzemski
P - Jake Arrieta
P - Félix Bautista
P - Jason Isringhausen
P - Grayson Rodriguez
P- Jimmy Yacabonis
Utility - Ryan Mountcastle
Manager - Buck Britton
25th Season
Voted on by fans in 2017
C - Matt Wieters
1B - Christian Walker
2B - Jonathan Schoop
3B - Butch Huskey
SS - Jose Reyes
OF - Dariel Alvarez
OF - Jeromy Burnitz
OF - Angel Pagan
P - Jake Arrieta (Picture shown to right)
P - Zach Britton
P - Jason Isringhausen
P - Chris Tillman
Utility - David Wright
Manager - Ron Johnson
General Manager - Dave Rosenfield
10th Season
Voted on by fans in 2002
C - Jason Phillips
1B - Roberto Petagine
2B - Marco Scutaro
3B - Butch Huskey (Picture shown to right)
SS - Rey Ordóñez
OF - Benny Agbayani
OF - Jeromy Burnitz
OF - Melvin Mora
P - Octavio Dotel
P - Jason Isringhausen
P - Bobby Jones
P - Rick Reed
Utility - Matt Franco